[Senate Document 106-4]
[From the U.S. Government Publishing Office]
106th Congress S. Doc.
SENATE
1st Session 106-4
_______________________________________________________________________
PROCEEDINGS OF THE
UNITED STATES SENATE
IN THE
IMPEACHMENT TRIAL OF PRESIDENT WILLIAM JEFFERSON CLINTON
VOLUME III: DEPOSITIONS AND AFFIDAVITS
VOLUME III OF IV
February 12, 1999.--Ordered to be printed
OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OF THE SENATE
Gary Sisco, Secretary
Sharon A. Zelaska, Assistant Secretary
Ronald Kavulick and Jerald D. Linnell, Chief Reporters of Debates
Bruce E. Kasold, Chief Counsel
Keith Simmons, Counsel
------
UNANIMOUS CONSENT AGREEMENT
In the Senate of the United States
February 12, 1999
Mr. LOTT. I ask unanimous consent that the Secretary be
authorized to include these statements [of Senators explaining
their votes], along with the full record of the Senate's
proceedings, the filings by the parties, and the supplemental
materials admitted into evidence by the Senate, in a Senate
document printed under the supervision of the Secretary of the
Senate, that will complete the documentation of the Senate's
handling of these impeachment proceedings.
The CHIEF JUSTICE. Without objection, it is so ordered.
To the memory of Raymond Scott Bates,
Legislative Clerk of the Senate,
who, until his untimely and tragic accidental death on February
5, 1999, in the midst of these proceedings, brought to the
conduct of this trial the constant dedication, skill, and
professionalism that characterized his Senate career. Scott
represented the best of the Senate staff who work tirelessly to
support the institution and its members.
FOREWORD
----------
This document contains the full record of the United States
Senate proceedings in the impeachment trial of President
William Jefferson Clinton. Its purpose is to preserve for the
future use of the Senate, the American people, and historians
the formal record of the only Presidential impeachment trial of
the 20th century. Together with the 24-volume Senate Document
106-3, which contains all publicly available materials
submitted to or produced by the Judiciary Committee of the
House of Representatives, these four volumes represent the
entire official record of the impeachment actions against
President Clinton.\1\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\ The Senate, by a unanimous-consent agreement of February 12,
1999, authorized the Secretary of the Senate to oversee the printing of
the Senate proceedings in order to complete the documentation of the
impeachment trial.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The present four volumes include the Senate proceedings in
open session; filings by the parties; supplemental materials
received in evidence that were not part of the House record,
such as affidavits and depositions; floor statements of
Senators in open session expressing their views regarding the
proceedings; and statements delivered in closed deliberations
that individual Senators elected to make public.
The document is divided into four sections--
Volume I: Preliminary Proceedings
Volume II: Floor Trial Proceedings
Volume III: Depositions and Affidavits
Volume IV: Statements of Senators Regarding the
Impeachment Trial of President William Jefferson
Clinton
Volume I: Preliminary Proceedings
This volume contains the portion of the Senate proceedings
that occurred before the actual trial commenced. On December
19, 1998, the House of Representatives adopted two articles of
impeachment against President Clinton (House Resolution 611,
105th Congress) and a subsequent resolution appointing managers
on the part of the House (House Resolution 614, 105th
Congress).
Because the Senate of the 105th Congress had already
completed its business and adjourned sine die, the House
managers, in the late afternoon of December 19, 1998, delivered
the articles of impeachment to the Secretary of the Senate. The
Senate of the 106th Congress convened and organized on January
6, 1999, and the House notified the Senate that it had
reappointed the managers (House Resolution 10, 106th Congress).
On January 7, 1999, the House managers exhibited the articles
of impeachment to the Senate and the Chief Justice of the
United States, as presiding officer during the impeachment
trial, took the prescribed oath, as did all Senators.
On January 8, 1999, the Senate unanimously directed that
the summons be issued to President Clinton and that his answer
to the articles be filed, together with the response of the
House of Representatives (Senate Resolution 16, 106th
Congress). This resolution admitted into evidence the materials
submitted by the House Judiciary Committee and authorized their
publication. It also allowed the parties to file preliminary
motions (none was filed), established a schedule for the filing
of trial briefs by the parties, and established further
procedures for the conduct of the trial. Although all these
documents were previously printed in Senate Document 106-2--as
well as the text of the provisions of the United States
Constitution applicable to impeachment and the Rules of
Procedure and Practice of the Senate When Sitting in
Impeachment Trials--they are reprinted here for ease of
reference.
Volume II: Floor Trial Proceedings
This volume reproduces the full record of the Senate floor
proceedings in the impeachment trial as provided under Senate
Resolution 16. The resolution first permitted the parties an
extended period to make their presentations. The managers
presented their case on behalf of the House of Representatives
on January 14, 15, and 16, 1999. Counsel for the President
presented their case on January 19 and 20, 1999. The Senate
then devoted January 22 and 23, 1999, to posing questions to
the House managers and counsel.
Senate Resolution 16 also provided that, at the end of the
question-and-answer period, the Senate would consider
separately a motion to dismiss and a motion to subpoena
witnesses and to present additional evidence not in the record.
On January 25, 1999, the Senate heard argument on the motion to
dismiss and, on January 26, 1999, considered the motion by the
House managers to call witnesses and admit additional evidence.
The Senate voted to deny the motion to dismiss and to grant the
motion to subpoena witnesses.
On January 28, 1999, the Senate established procedures for
the taking of depositions (Senate Resolution 30), and three
witnesses were deposed on February 1, 2, and 3, 1999. On
February 4, 1999, the Senate heard argument and voted on
motions to admit the deposition testimony into evidence, to
call witnesses to testify on the Senate floor, and to proceed
directly to closing arguments. The portions of the deposition
transcripts admitted into evidence are reproduced in this
volume, while the full transcripts of the three depositions
appear in Volume III. Both parties presented evidence to the
Senate on February 6, 1999.
On February 8, 1999, the parties presented final arguments
to the Senate. The Senate then considered proposals by various
Senators to suspend the Senate impeachment rules to permit
deliberation in open session, but all deliberations on motions
and on the articles of impeachment occurred in closed session.
(The proceedings in closed session are not published here, but
statements that Senators elected to make public are printed in
Volume IV.) Volume II concludes with the record of the February
12, 1999, vote and judgment of the Senate to acquit President
Clinton on both articles of impeachment.
Volume III: Depositions and Affidavits
This volume reproduces the complete transcripts of the
depositions taken by the Senate of witnesses Monica S.
Lewinsky, Vernon E. Jordan, Jr., and Sidney Blumenthal. It also
contains the affidavits of Christopher Hitchens, Carol Blue,
and R. Scott Armstrong, which were admitted into evidence by a
unanimous-consent agreement of February 12, 1999.
Volume IV: Statements of Senators Regarding the Impeachment Trial of
President William Jefferson Clinton
By unanimous consent, the Senate agreed to provide each
Senator an opportunity to place in the Congressional Record a
statement describing his or her own views on the impeachment.
The statement could, if a Senator so chose, be a statement he
or she had delivered during closed deliberations. Since not all
Senators chose to publish their remarks, the fact that a
statement of a particular Senator does not appear in Volume IV
does not mean that the Senator did not address the Senate
during its closed deliberations.
The publication of these four volumes, supplemented with
Senate Document 106-3, contributes to a fuller understanding of
the way in which the Senate conducted these important and
historic proceedings.
Gary Sisco,
Secretary of the Senate.
C O N T E N T S
----------
Page
Foreword......................................................... V
VOLUME I: PRELIMINARY PROCEEDINGS
Constitutional Provisions on Impeachment......................... 1
Rules of Procedure and Practice in the Senate When Sitting on
Impeachment Trials............................................. 3
January 6, 1999
Statements of Senators Lott and Reid regarding access to Senate
floor, galleries, and wing during impeachment proceedings [145
Cong. Rec. S7 (daily ed. Jan. 6, 1999)]........................ 15
Unanimous-consent agreement on access to Senate floor, galleries
and wing during impeachment proceedings [145 Cong. Rec. S7-8
(daily ed. Jan. 6, 1999)]...................................... 16
Notice of receipt of message from House of Representatives by
Secretary of the Senate during sine die adjournment announcing
impeachment of President and appointment of Managers [145 Cong.
Rec. S14-15 (daily ed. Jan. 6, 1999)]\1\....................... 17
Notice of receipt of message from House of Representatives
announcing reappointment of Managers, H. Res. 10, 106th Cong.
(1999) [145 Cong. Rec. S15 (daily ed. Jan. 6, 1999)]\2\........ 19
Unanimous-consent agreement on receiving Managers and requesting
attendance of Chief Justice [145 Cong. Rec. S36 (daily ed. Jan.
6, 1999)]...................................................... 20
Message from House of Representatives announcing reappointment of
Managers [145 Cong. Rec. S36 (daily ed. Jan. 6, 1999)]......... 22
H. Res. 611, 105th Cong. (1998).................................. 23
H. Res. 614, 105th Cong. (1998).................................. 29
H. Res. 10, 106th Cong. (1999)................................... 31
Sample of Senate Impeachment Trial gallery tickets............... 33
January 7, 1999
Exhibition of Articles of Impeachment Against William Jefferson
Clinton, President of the United States [145 Cong. Rec. S39-41
(daily ed. Jan. 7, 1999)]...................................... 35
Resolution by Senators Lott and Daschle to authorize taking
photograph in Senate Chamber of swearing-in, S. Res. 11, 106th
Cong. (1999) [145 Cong. Rec. S41 (daily ed. Jan. 7, 1999)]..... 38
Appointment of escort committee to receive Chief Justice [145
Cong. Rec. S41 (daily ed. Jan. 7, 1999)]....................... 38
Administration of oath to Chief Justice and Members of Senate
[145 Cong. Rec. S41-42 (daily ed. Jan. 7, 1999)]............... 40
S. Res. 11, 106th Cong. (1999)................................... 41
Photographs taken pursuant to S. Res. 11, 106th Cong. (1999)..... 42
January 8, 1999
Resolution by Senators Lott and Daschle providing for issuance of
summons to William Jefferson Clinton, President of the United
States, and establishing trial procedures, S. Res. 16, 106th
Cong. (1999) [145 Cong. Rec. S50 (daily ed. Jan. 8, 1999)]..... 45
Rollcall Vote No. 1 [145 Cong. Rec. S50 (daily ed. Jan. 8,
1999)]..................................................... 47
S. Res. 16, 106th Cong. (1999)................................... 48
Writ of Summons (January 8, 1999)................................ 53
January 11, 1999
Answer of President William Jefferson Clinton to Articles of
Impeachment (January 11, 1999)................................. 58
Trial Memorandum of United States House of Representatives, with
Appendix (January 11, 1999).................................... 71
January 13, 1999
Trial Memorandum of President William Jefferson Clinton (January
13, 1999)...................................................... 365
Appendix to Trial Memorandum of President William Jefferson
Clinton (January 20, 1999)\3\.................................. 500
January 14, 1999
Replication of House of Representatives to Answer of President
William Jefferson Clinton to Articles of Impeachment (January
14, 1999)...................................................... 735
Reply of United States House of Representatives to Trial
Memorandum of President William Jefferson Clinton (January 14,
1999).......................................................... 740
VOLUME II: FLOOR TRIAL PROCEEDINGS
January 14, 1999
Resolution by Senator Lott to authorize installation of
appropriate equipment and furniture in Senate Chamber, S. Res.
17, 106th Cong. (1999) [145 Cong. Rec. S59 (daily ed. Jan. 14,
1999)]......................................................... 773
Unanimous-consent agreement on floor privileges during closed
session [145 Cong. Rec. S59-60 (daily ed. Jan. 14, 1999)]...... 774
Unanimous-consent agreement on authority to print documents filed
by the parties and other impeachment documents \4\ [145 Cong.
Rec. S60 (daily ed. Jan. 14, 1999)]............................ 775
Writ of Summons and Return of Service by Sergeant at Arms
(January 8, 1999) [145 Cong. Rec. S60-61 (daily ed. Jan. 14,
1999)]......................................................... 776
Answer of President William Jefferson Clinton to Articles of
Impeachment (January 11, 1999) [145 Cong. Rec. S61-63 (daily
ed. Jan. 14, 1999)]............................................ 778
Trial Memorandum of United States House of Representatives, with
Appendix (January 11, 1999) [145 Cong. Rec. S63-190 (daily ed.
Jan. 14, 1999)]................................................ 783
Trial Memorandum of President William Jefferson Clinton (January
13, 1999) [145 Cong. Rec. S191-214 (daily ed. Jan. 14, 1999)].. 938
Replication of House of Representatives to Answer of President
William Jefferson Clinton to Articles of Impeachment [145 Cong.
Rec. S214-15 (daily ed. Jan. 14, 1999)]........................ 992
Reply of United States House of Representatives to Trial
Memorandum of President William Jefferson Clinton (January 14,
1999) [145 Cong. Rec. S215-21 (daily ed. Jan. 14, 1999)]....... 994
Presentation of case by House Managers [145 Cong. Rec. S221-51
(daily ed. Jan. 14, 1999)]..................................... 1007
S. Res. 17, 106th Cong. (1999)................................... 1087
Floor plan and seating arrangements in Senate Chamber for
impeachment trial proceedings.................................. 1089
January 15, 1999
Presentation of case by House Managers [145 Cong. Rec. S260-79
(daily ed. Jan. 15, 1999)]..................................... 1091
January 16, 1999
Presentation of case by House Managers [145 Cong. Rec. S281-300
(daily ed. Jan. 16, 1999)]..................................... 1144
January 19, 1999
Presentation of case for President [145 Cong. Rec. S483-95 (daily
ed. Jan. 19, 1999)]............................................ 1195
Statement of Senator Feingold in legislative session [145 Cong.
Rec. S720-21 (daily ed. Jan. 19, 1999)]........................ 1225
January 20, 1999
Statement of Senator Harkin in legislative session [145 Cong.
Rec. S729-32 (daily ed. Jan. 20, 1999)]........................ 1227
Statement of Senator Wellstone in legislative session [145 Cong.
Rec. S732-33 (daily ed. Jan. 20, 1999)]........................ 1234
Presentation of case for President [145 Cong. Rec. S810-30 (daily
ed. Jan. 20, 1999)]............................................ 1237
January 21, 1999
Presentation of case for President [145 Cong. Rec. S832-48 (daily
ed. Jan. 21, 1999)]............................................ 1292
Statement of Senator Lott regarding procedure for question-and-
answer period [145 Cong. Rec. S848 (daily ed. Jan. 21, 1999)].. 1335
Notice of Intent to Suspend the Rules of the Senate by Senators
Harkin and Wellstone [145 Cong. Rec. S848-49 (daily ed. Jan.
21, 1999)]..................................................... 1336
January 22, 1999
Questions submitted by Senators and answers of House Managers and
counsel for President [145 Cong. Rec. S869-92 (daily ed. Jan.
22, 1999)]..................................................... 1338
Notice of Intent to Suspend the Rules of the Senate by Senators
Hutchison, Specter, Lieberman, Hagel, Collins, and Snowe [145
Cong. Rec. S892 (daily ed. Jan. 22, 1999)]..................... 1396
Sample question card used by Senators............................ 1398
January 23, 1999
Questions submitted by Senators and answers of House Managers and
counsel for President [145 Cong. Rec. S933-56 (daily ed. Jan.
23, 1999)]..................................................... 1400
Letter from Senator Harkin to Chief Justice (January 23, 1999)... 1461
January 25, 1999
Letter from Chief Justice to Senator Harkin (January 25, 1999)... 1462
Unanimous-consent agreement on argument on motion to dismiss and
on motion to open debate [145 Cong. Rec. S962-63 (daily ed.
Jan. 25, 1999)]................................................ 1466
Motion of Senator Byrd to dismiss impeachment proceedings [145
Cong. Rec. S963 (daily ed. Jan. 25, 1999)]..................... 1469
Argument of House Managers in opposition to motion to dismiss
[145 Cong. Rec. S963-65 (daily ed. Jan. 25, 1999)]............. 1469
Argument of counsel for President in support of motion to dismiss
[145 Cong. Rec. S965-70 (daily ed. Jan. 25, 1999)]............. 1476
Rebuttal argument of House Managers in opposition to motion to
dismiss [145 Cong. Rec. S970-73 (daily ed. Jan. 25, 1999)]..... 1489
Motion to Suspend the Rules of the Senate by Senators Harkin,
Wellstone, Feingold, Leahy, Lieberman, Johnson, Inouye,
Schumer, Wyden, Kerrey, Bayh, Torricelli, Lautenberg, Robb,
Dodd, Murray, Dorgan, Conrad, Kennedy, Kerry, Durbin, Boxer,
Graham, Bryan, Landrieu, and Mikulski [145 Cong. Rec. S973-74
(daily ed. Jan. 25, 1999)]..................................... 1495
Rollcall Vote No. 2 [145 Cong. Rec. S973-74 (daily ed. Jan.
25, 1999)]................................................. 1496
Closed deliberation [145 Cong. Rec. S974 (daily ed. Jan. 25,
1999)]......................................................... 1497
Statement of Senator Mikulski in legislative session [145 Cong.
Rec. S987 (daily ed. Jan. 25, 1999)]........................... 1498
January 26, 1999
Motion and Memorandum in Support of Motion of United States House
of Representatives for Appearance of Witnesses at Deposition
and to Admit Evidence Not in Record (January 26, 1999)......... 1500
Motion of House of Representatives for appearance of witnesses
and admission of evidence [145 Cong. Rec. S991-92 (daily ed.
Jan. 26, 1999)]................................................ 1531
Argument of House Managers in support of motion for appearance of
witnesses and admission of evidence [145 Cong. Rec. S992-99
(daily ed. Jan. 26, 1999)]..................................... 1532
Unanimous-consent agreement on order of consideration of and
deliberation on motions to suspend rules and for appearance of
witnesses and admission of evidence [145 Cong. Rec. S999-1000
(daily ed. Jan. 26, 1999)]..................................... 1552
Argument of House Managers in support of motion for appearance of
witnesses and admission of evidence, cont. [145 Cong. Rec.
S1000-02 (daily ed. Jan. 26, 1999)]............................ 1552
Argument of counsel for President in opposition to appearance of
witnesses and admission of evidence [145 Cong. Rec. S1002-07
(daily ed. Jan. 26, 1999)]..................................... 1558
Rebuttal argument of House Managers in support of motion for
appearance of witnesses and admission of evidence [145 Cong.
Rec. S1007-09 (daily ed. Jan. 26, 1999)]....................... 1571
Motion of Senator Harkin to Suspend the Rules of the Senate [145
Cong. Rec. S1010 (daily ed. Jan. 26, 1999)].................... 1578
Rollcall Vote No. 3 [145 Cong. Rec. S1010 (daily ed. Jan. 26,
1999)]..................................................... 1579
Closed deliberation [145 Cong. Rec. S1010 (daily ed. Jan. 26,
1999)]......................................................... 1580
January 27, 1999
Vote on motion to dismiss impeachment proceedings [145 Cong. Rec.
S1017-18 (daily ed. Jan. 27, 1999)]............................ 1582
Rollcall Vote No. 4 [145 Cong. Rec. S1017-18 (daily ed. Jan.
27, 1999)]................................................. 1582
Vote on motion for appearance of witnesses and admission of
evidence [145 Cong. Rec. S1018 (daily ed. Jan. 27, 1999)]...... 1582
Rollcall Vote No. 5 [145 Cong. Rec. S1018 (daily ed. Jan. 27,
1999)]..................................................... 1583
Materials admitted into evidence:
Affidavit of Barry W. Ward, Law Clerk to Honorable Susan
Webber Wright, U.S. District Judge for Eastern District of
Arkansas................................................... 1585
Declaration of T. Wesley Holmes, with attachments............ 1586
Telephone records documenting conversations between President
Clinton and Monica S. Lewinsky............................. 1594
Statement of Senator Hollings in legislative session [145 Cong.
Rec. S1028-29 (daily ed. Jan. 27, 1999)]....................... 1595
Statements of Senator Abraham in legislative session [145 Cong.
Rec. S1029-30, 1031 (daily ed. Jan. 27, 1999)]
record of impeachment proceedings [145 Cong. Rec. S1457�0958 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601992
I21Closed deliberation [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601993
A
I21Vote on first article of impeachment [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601994
I23Rollcall Vote No. 17 [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 9, 1999)] I601995
I21Vote on second article of impeachment [145 Cong. Rec. S1458�0959 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601997
I23Rollcall Vote No. 18 [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 9, 1999)] I601997
I21Order to Secretary of the Senate to communicate judgment of Senate to Secretary of State and House of Representatives [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601998
I21Statement of Chief Justice [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601998
I21Resolution by Senators Lott and Daschle expressing gratitude of Senate to Chief Justice of the United States, S. Res. 37, 106th Cong. (1999) [145 Cong. Rec. S1459�0960 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601999
I21Unanimous-consent agreement on admitting affidavits into evidence and making full deposition transcripts part of the record [145 Cong. Rec. S1460 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I602000
I21Adjournment sine die [145 Cong. R
aily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601992
I21Closed deliberation [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601993
A
I21Vote on first article of impeachment [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601994
I23Rollcall Vote No. 17 [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 9, 1999)] I601995
I21Vote on second article of impeachment [145 Cong. Rec. S1458�0959 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601997
I23Rollcall Vote No. 18 [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 9, 1999)] I601997
I21Order to Secretary of the Senate to communicate judgment of Senate to Secretary of State and House of Representatives [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601998
I21Statement of Chief Justice [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601998
I21Resolution by Senators Lott and Daschle expressing gratitude of Senate to Chief Justice of the United States, S. Res. 37, 106th Cong. (1999) [145 Cong. Rec. S1459�0960 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601999
I21Unanimous-consent agreement on admitting affidavits into evidence and making full deposition transcripts part of the record [145 Cong. Rec. S1460 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I602000
I21Adjournment sine die [145 Cong. R
Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601993
A
I21Vote on first article of impeachment [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601994
I23Rollcall Vote No. 17 [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 9, 1999)] I601995
I21Vote on second article of impeachment [145 Cong. Rec. S1458�0959 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601997
I23Rollcall Vote No. 18 [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 9, 1999)] I601997
I21Order to Secretary of the Senate to communicate judgment of Senate to Secretary of State and House of Representatives [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601998
I21Statement of Chief Justice [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601998
I21Resolution by Senators Lott and Daschle expressing gratitude of Senate to Chief Justice of the United States, S. Res. 37, 106th Cong. (1999) [145 Cong. Rec. S1459�0960 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601999
I21Unanimous-consent agreement on admitting affidavits into evidence and making full deposition transcripts part of the record [145 Cong. Rec. S1460 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I602000
I21Adjournment sine die [145 Cong. R
liberation [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601993
A
I21Vote on first article of impeachment [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601994
I23Rollcall Vote No. 17 [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 9, 1999)] I601995
I21Vote on second article of impeachment [145 Cong. Rec. S1458�0959 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601997
I23Rollcall Vote No. 18 [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 9, 1999)] I601997
I21Order to Secretary of the Senate to communicate judgment of Senate to Secretary of State and House of Representatives [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601998
I21Statement of Chief Justice [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601998
I21Resolution by Senators Lott and Daschle expressing gratitude of Senate to Chief Justice of the United States, S. Res. 37, 106th Cong. (1999) [145 Cong. Rec. S1459�0960 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601999
I21Unanimous-consent agreement on admitting affidavits into evidence and making full deposition transcripts part of the record [145 Cong. Rec. S1460 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I602000
I21Adjournment sine die [145 Cong. R
tors in Congressional Record and for printing of Senate document containing full record of impeachment proceedings [145 Cong. Rec. S1457�0958 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601992
I21Closed deliberation [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601993
A
I21Vote on first article of impeachment [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601994
I23Rollcall Vote No. 17 [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 9, 1999)] I601995
I21Vote on second article of impeachment [145 Cong. Rec. S1458�0959 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601997
I23Rollcall Vote No. 18 [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 9, 1999)] I601997
I21Order to Secretary of the Senate to communicate judgment of Senate to Secretary of State and House of Representatives [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601998
I21Statement of Chief Justice [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601998
I21Resolution by Senators Lott and Daschle expressing gratitude of Senate to Chief Justice of the United States, S. Res. 37, 106th Cong. (1999) [145 Cong. Rec. S1459�0960 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601999
I21Unanimous-consent agreement on admitting affidavits into evidence and making full deposition transcripts part of the record [145 Cong. Rec. S1460 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I602000
I21Adjournment sine die [145 Cong. R
[145 Cong. Rec. S1455 (daily ed. Feb. 11, 1999)] I601988
I21S. Res. 36, 106th Cong. (1999) I601989
I74February 12, 1999
I21Unanimous-consent agreement on printing of statements of Senators in Congressional Record and for printing of Senate document containing full record of impeachment proceedings [145 Cong. Rec. S1457�0958 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601992
I21Closed deliberation [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601993
A
I21Vote on first article of impeachment [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601994
I23Rollcall Vote No. 17 [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 9, 1999)] I601995
I21Vote on second article of impeachment [145 Cong. Rec. S1458�0959 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601997
I23Rollcall Vote No. 18 [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 9, 1999)] I601997
I21Order to Secretary of the Senate to communicate judgment of Senate to Secretary of State and House of Representatives [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601998
I21Statement of Chief Justice [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601998
I21Resolution by Senators Lott and Daschle expressing gratitude of Senate to Chief Justice of the United States, S. Res. 37, 106th Cong. (1999) [145 Cong. Rec. S1459�0960 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601999
I21Unanimous-consent agreement on admitting affidavits into evidence and making full deposition transcripts part of the record [145 Cong. Rec. S1460 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I602000
I21Adjournment sine die [145 Cong. R
record of impeachment proceedings [145 Cong. Rec. S1457�0958 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601992
I21Closed deliberation [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601993
A
I21Vote on first article of impeachment [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601994
I23Rollcall Vote No. 17 [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 9, 1999)] I601995
I21Vote on second article of impeachment [145 Cong. Rec. S1458�0959 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601997
I23Rollcall Vote No. 18 [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 9, 1999)] I601997
I21Order to Secretary of the Senate to communicate judgment of Senate to Secretary of State and House of Representatives [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601998
I21Statement of Chief Justice [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601998
I21Resolution by Senators Lott and Daschle expressing gratitude of Senate to Chief Justice of the United States, S. Res. 37, 106th Cong. (1999) [145 Cong. Rec. S1459�0960 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601999
I21Unanimous-consent agreement on admitting affidavits into evidence and making full deposition transcripts part of the record [145 Cong. Rec. S1460 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I602000
I21Adjournment sine die [145 Cong. R
, 1999)] I601992
I21Closed deliberation [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601993
A
I21Vote on first article of impeachment [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601994
I23Rollcall Vote No. 17 [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 9, 1999)] I601995
I21Vote on second article of impeachment [145 Cong. Rec. S1458�0959 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601997
I23Rollcall Vote No. 18 [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 9, 1999)] I601997
I21Order to Secretary of the Senate to communicate judgment of Senate to Secretary of State and House of Representatives [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601998
I21Statement of Chief Justice [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601998
I21Resolution by Senators Lott and Daschle expressing gratitude of Senate to Chief Justice of the United States, S. Res. 37, 106th Cong. (1999) [145 Cong. Rec. S1459�0960 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601999
I21Unanimous-consent agreement on admitting affidavits into evidence and making full deposition transcripts part of the record [145 Cong. Rec. S1460 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I602000
I21Adjournment sine die [145 Cong. R
containing full record of impeachment proceedings [145 Cong. Rec. S1457�0958 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601992
I21Closed deliberation [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601993
A
I21Vote on first article of impeachment [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601994
I23Rollcall Vote No. 17 [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 9, 1999)] I601995
I21Vote on second article of impeachment [145 Cong. Rec. S1458�0959 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601997
I23Rollcall Vote No. 18 [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 9, 1999)] I601997
I21Order to Secretary of the Senate to communicate judgment of Senate to Secretary of State and House of Representatives [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601998
I21Statement of Chief Justice [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601998
I21Resolution by Senators Lott and Daschle expressing gratitude of Senate to Chief Justice of the United States, S. Res. 37, 106th Cong. (1999) [145 Cong. Rec. S1459�0960 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601999
I21Unanimous-consent agreement on admitting affidavits into evidence and making full deposition transcripts part of the record [145 Cong. Rec. S1460 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I602000
I21Adjournment sine die [145 Cong. R
chment proceedings [145 Cong. Rec. S1457�0958 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601992
I21Closed deliberation [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601993
A
I21Vote on first article of impeachment [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601994
I23Rollcall Vote No. 17 [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 9, 1999)] I601995
I21Vote on second article of impeachment [145 Cong. Rec. S1458�0959 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601997
I23Rollcall Vote No. 18 [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 9, 1999)] I601997
I21Order to Secretary of the Senate to communicate judgment of Senate to Secretary of State and House of Representatives [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601998
I21Statement of Chief Justice [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601998
I21Resolution by Senators Lott and Daschle expressing gratitude of Senate to Chief Justice of the United States, S. Res. 37, 106th Cong. (1999) [145 Cong. Rec. S1459�0960 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I601999
I21Unanimous-consent agreement on admitting affidavits into evidence and making full deposition transcripts part of the record [145 Cong. Rec. S1460 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)] I602000
I21Adjournment sine die [145 Cong. R
Statement of Senator Lieberman in legislative session [145 Cong.
Rec. S1030-31 (daily ed. Jan. 27, 1999)]....................... 1599
January 28, 1999
Resolution by Senator Lott and amendments thereto by Senator
Daschle relating to procedures for taking depositions, S. Res.
30, 106th Cong. (1999) [145 Cong. Rec. S1069-73 (daily ed. Jan.
28, 1999)]..................................................... 1605
Rollcall Vote No. 6 [145 Cong. Rec. S1071 (daily ed. Jan. 28,
1999)]..................................................... 1608
Rollcall Vote No. 7 [145 Cong. Rec. S1071-72 (daily ed. Jan.
28, 1999)]................................................. 1609
Rollcall Vote No. 8 [145 Cong. Rec. S1072 (daily ed. Jan. 28,
1999)]..................................................... 1610
Unanimous-consent agreement on taking of depositions [145 Cong.
Rec. S1073-74 (daily ed. Jan. 28, 1999)]....................... 1614
S. Res. 30, 106th Cong. (1999)................................... 1616
Leadership protocol on depositions pursuant to S. Res. 16 and S.
Res. 30 (January 28, 1999)..................................... 1623
Statement of Senator Cleland in legislative session [145 Cong.
Rec. S1105-06 (daily ed. Jan. 28, 1999)]....................... 1624
Statement of Senator Feingold in legislative session [145 Cong.
Rec. S1106-07 (daily ed. Jan. 28, 1999)]....................... 1628
Statements of Senator Leahy in legislative session [145 Cong.
Rec. S1107-10 (daily ed. Jan. 28, 1999)]....................... 1631
January 29, 1999
Subpoenas issued for witnesses to appear at depositions:
Monica S. Lewinsky (January 29, 1999)........................ 1639
Vernon E. Jordan, Jr. (January 29, 1999)..................... 1642
Sidney Blumenthal (January 29, 1999)......................... 1645
February 3, 1999
Statement of Senator Dorgan in legislative session [145 Cong.
Rec. S1117-19 (daily ed. Feb. 3, 1999)]........................ 1648
February 4, 1999
Motion of House of Representatives for admission of evidence,
appearance of witnesses, and presentation of evidence [145
Cong. Rec. S1199-1200 (daily ed. Feb. 4, 1999)]................ 1653
Argument of House Managers in support of motion for admission of
evidence, appearance of witnesses, and presentation of evidence
[145 Cong. Rec. S1200-05 (daily ed. Feb. 4, 1999)]............. 1654
Argument of counsel for President in opposition to motion for
admission of evidence, appearance of witnesses, and
presentation of evidence [145 Cong. Rec. S1205-07 (daily ed.
Feb. 4, 1999)]................................................. 1667
Rebuttal argument of House Managers in support of motion for
admission of evidence, appearance of witnesses, and
presentation of evidence [145 Cong. Rec. S1207-08 (daily ed.
Feb. 4, 1999)]................................................. 1673
Votes on motions for admission of evidence, appearance of
witnesses, and presentation of evidence [145 Cong. Rec. S1209-
10 (daily ed. Feb. 4, 1999)]................................... 1677
Rollcall Vote No. 9 [145 Cong. Rec. S1209 (daily ed. Feb. 4,
1999)]..................................................... 1677
Rollcall Vote No. 10 [145 Cong. Rec. S1209 (daily ed. Feb. 4,
1999)]..................................................... 1678
Rollcall Vote No. 11 [145 Cong. Rec. S1209-10 (daily ed. Feb.
4, 1999)].................................................. 1680
Rollcall Vote No. 12 [145 Cong. Rec. S1210 (daily ed. Feb. 4,
1999)]..................................................... 1681
Motion of Senator Daschle to proceed to closing arguments [145
Cong. Rec. S1210 (daily ed. Feb. 4, 1999)]..................... 1681
Rollcall Vote No. 13 [145 Cong. Rec. S1210 (daily ed. Feb. 4,
1999)]..................................................... 1682
Motion of counsel for President for provision of written notice
by House Managers of designated video excerpts [145 Cong. Rec.
S1210-11 (daily ed. Feb. 4, 1999)]............................. 1683
Rollcall Vote No. 14 [145 Cong. Rec. S1210-11 (daily ed. Feb.
4, 1999)].................................................. 1685
Unanimous-consent agreement on printing partial transcripts of
depositions in Congressional Record [145 Cong. Rec. S1212
(daily ed. Feb. 4, 1999)]...................................... 1687
Materials admitted into evidence:
Deposition of Monica S. Lewinsky (Feb. 1, 1999) (partial
transcript) [145 Cong. Rec. S1212-29 (daily ed. Feb. 4,
1999)]..................................................... 1687
Deposition of Vernon E. Jordan, Jr. (Feb. 2, 1999) (partial
transcript) [145 Cong. Rec. S1229-46 (daily ed. Feb. 4,
1999)]..................................................... 1736
Deposition of Sidney Blumenthal (Feb. 3, 1999) (partial
transcript) [145 Cong. Rec. S1246-54 (daily ed. Feb. 4,
1999)]..................................................... 1776
February 6, 1999
Presentation of evidence by House Managers [145 Cong. Rec. S1290-
1303 (daily ed. Feb. 6, 1999)]................................. 1800
Presentation of evidence by counsel for President [145 Cong. Rec.
S1303-15 (daily ed. Feb. 6, 1999)]............................. 1836
Rebuttal presentation of evidence by House Managers [145 Cong.
Rec. S1315-17 (daily ed. Feb. 6, 1999)]........................ 1866
Unanimous-consent request of Senator Boxer to show additional
deposition testimony [145 Cong. Rec. S1317-18 (daily ed. Feb.
6, 1999)]...................................................... 1873
Notice of Intent to Suspend the Rules of the Senate by Senators
Lott, Daschle, Hutchison, Harkin, Collins, Specter, Wellstone,
and Leahy [145 Cong. Rec. S1318 (daily ed. Feb. 6, 1999)]...... 1873
Statements of Senator Dodd in legislative session [145 Cong. Rec.
S1330-32 (daily ed. Feb. 6, 1999)]............................. 1874
February 8, 1999
Unanimous-consent request of Senator Lott for admission of
affidavits into evidence [145 Cong. Rec. S1337 (daily ed. Feb.
8, 1999)]...................................................... 1882
Final arguments of House Managers [145 Cong. Rec. S1337-44 (daily
ed. Feb. 8, 1999)]............................................. 1882
Final arguments of counsel for President [145 Cong. Rec. S1344-54
(daily ed. Feb. 8, 1999)]...................................... 1900
Rebuttal final arguments of House Managers [145 Cong. Rec. S1354-
65 (daily ed. Feb. 8, 1999)]................................... 1925
Notice of Intent to Suspend the Rules of the Senate by Senators
Daschle, Lott, Hutchison, Harkin, Wellstone, Collins, Specter,
and Leahy [145 Cong. Rec. S1365 (daily ed. Feb. 8, 1999)]...... 1955
Notice of Intent to Suspend the Rules of the Senate by Senators
Daschle and Feinstein [145 Cong. Rec. S1380 (daily ed. Feb. 8,
1999)]......................................................... 1955
Letter from House Managers to Senators Lott and Daschle (Feb. 8,
1999).......................................................... 1956
February 9, 1999
Unanimous-consent request of Senator Specter to allow parties to
take additional discovery [145 Cong. Rec. S1385 (daily ed. Feb.
9, 1999)]...................................................... 1964
Motion of Senators Lott and Daschle to Suspend the Rules of the
Senate [145 Cong. Rec. S1385-86 (daily ed. Feb. 9, 1999)]...... 1964
Rollcall Vote No. 15 [145 Cong. Rec. S1386 (daily ed. Feb. 9,
1999)]..................................................... 1965
Motion of Senators Lott and Daschle to authorize Senators to
insert statements delivered in closed deliberations into
Congressional Record [145 Cong. Rec. S1386-87 (daily ed. Feb.
9, 1999)]...................................................... 1966
Motion of Senator Lott to close doors of Senate for final
deliberation [145 Cong. Rec. S1387 (daily ed. Feb. 9, 1999)]... 1970
Rollcall Vote No. 16 [145 Cong. Rec. S1387 (daily ed. Feb. 9,
1999)]..................................................... 1970
Closed deliberation [145 Cong. Rec. S1388 (daily ed. Feb. 9,
1999)]......................................................... 1971
Statement of Senator Leahy in legislative session [145 Cong. Rec.
S1406-09 (daily ed. Feb. 9, 1999)]............................. 1971
Statement of Senator Feingold in legislative session [145 Cong.
Rec. S1409 (daily ed. Feb. 9, 1999)]........................... 1978
Statement of Senator Dodd in legislative session [145 Cong. Rec.
S1409-10 (daily ed. Feb. 9, 1999)]............................. 1980
February 10, 1999
Colloquy on record of closed deliberations [145 Cong. Rec. S1411-
12 (daily ed. Feb. 10, 1999)].................................. 1982
Closed deliberation [145 Cong. Rec. S1412 (daily ed. Feb. 10,
1999)]......................................................... 1984
February 11, 1999
Closed deliberation [145 Cong. Rec. S1437 (daily ed. Feb. 11,
1999)]......................................................... 1986
Resolution by Senators Lott, Daschle, McConnell and Dodd to
authorize taking photograph in Senate Chamber of impeachment
vote, S. Res. 36, 106th Cong. (1999) [145 Cong. Rec. S1437-38
(daily ed. Feb. 11, 1999)]..................................... 1987
Appointment of committee to escort Chief Justice from Senate
Chamber upon conclusion of impeachment trial [145 Cong. Rec.
S1454-55 (daily ed. Feb. 11, 1999)]............................ 1987
Unanimous-consent agreement on consideration of censure
resolution [145 Cong. Rec. S1455 (daily ed. Feb. 11, 1999)].... 1988
S. Res. 36, 106th Cong. (1999)................................... 1989
February 12, 1999
Unanimous-consent agreement on printing of statements of Senators
in Congressional Record and for printing of Senate document
containing full record of impeachment proceedings [145 Cong.
Rec. S1457-58 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)]....................... 1992
Closed deliberation [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 12,
1999)]......................................................... 1993
Vote on first article of impeachment [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily
ed. Feb. 12, 1999)]............................................ 1994
Rollcall Vote No. 17 [145 Cong. Rec. S1458 (daily ed. Feb. 9,
1999)]..................................................... 1995
Vote on second article of impeachment [145 Cong. Rec. S1458-59
(daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)]..................................... 1997
Rollcall Vote No. 18 [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 9,
1999)]..................................................... 1997
Order to Secretary of the Senate to communicate judgment of
Senate to Secretary of State and House of Representatives [145
Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)].................... 1998
Statement of Chief Justice [145 Cong. Rec. S1459 (daily ed. Feb.
12, 1999)]..................................................... 1998
Resolution by Senators Lott and Daschle expressing gratitude of
Senate to Chief Justice of the United States, S. Res. 37, 106th
Cong. (1999) [145 Cong. Rec. S1459-60 (daily ed. Feb. 12,
1999)]......................................................... 1999
Unanimous-consent agreement on admitting affidavits into evidence
and making full deposition transcripts part of the record [145
Cong. Rec. S1460 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)].................... 2000
Adjournment sine die [145 Cong. Rec. S1460 (daily ed. Feb. 12,
1999)]......................................................... 2000
Statements of Senators Lott, Daschle and Chafee in legislative
session [145 Cong. Rec. S1460 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)]....... 2001
Motion of Senator Feinstein in legislative session to suspend the
rules in order to permit the consideration of censure
resolution [145 Cong. Rec. S1462 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)].... 2002
Motion of Senator Gramm in legislative session to indefinitely
postpone consideration of motion to suspend rules [145 Cong.
Rec. S1462 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)].......................... 2002
Rollcall Vote No. 19 [145 Cong. Rec. S1462 (daily ed. Feb.
12, 1999)]................................................. 2003
Statement of Senator Feinstein in legislative session [145 Cong.
Rec. S1664-66 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)]....................... 2004
Statement of Senator Snowe in legislative session [145 Cong. Rec.
S1546-47 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)]............................ 2010
Statement of Senator Ashcroft in legislative session [145 Cong.
Rec. S1461 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)].......................... 2011
Statement of Senator Chafee in legislative session [145 Cong.
Rec. S1639 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)].......................... 2013
Statement of Senator Kohl in legislative session [145 Cong. Rec.
S1656 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)]............................... 2014
Resolution by Senator Hollings in legislative session to censure
President [145 Cong. Rec. S1657 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)]..... 2015
Statement of Senator Daschle in legislative session [145 Cong.
Rec. S1637-38 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)]....................... 2015
Statement of Senator Warner in legislative session [145 Cong.
Rec. S1667 (daily ed. Feb. 12, 1999)].......................... 2017
S. Res. 37, 106th Cong. (1999)................................... 2019
Photograph taken pursuant to S. Res. 36, 106th Cong. (1999)...... 2021
Legislative Clerk's tally sheets for Senate votes on articles of
impeachment.................................................... 2022
Judgment of United States Senate (Feb. 12, 1999)................. 2024
TABLE OF ROLLCALL VOTES
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Measure/
Vote No. Date Description Result Page
------------------------------------------------------------------------
1........ 1/8/99......... S. Res. 16........ Resolution Agreed 47
to 100-0.
2........ 1/25/99........ Harkin motion to Motion Rejected 1496
suspend the rules. 43-57.
3........ 1/26/99........ Harkin motion to Motion Rejected 1579
suspend the rules. 41-58.
4........ 1/27/99........ Byrd motion to Motion Rejected 1582
dismiss the 44-56.
impeachment
proceedings.
5........ 1/27/99........ House Managers' Motion Agreed to 1583
motion to 56-44.
subpoena
witnesses and
admit evidence
not in record.
6........ 1/28/99........ Daschle Amdt. No. Amendment 1608
1 to S. Res. 30. Rejected 44-54.
7........ 1/28/99........ Daschle Amdt. No. Amendment 1609
2 to S. Res. 30. Rejected 43-55.
8........ 1/28/99........ S. Res. 30 as Resolution Agreed 1610
amended. to 54-44.
9........ 2/4/99......... Division I of Motion Agreed to 1677
House Managers' 100-0.
motion re:
admission of
evidence.
10....... 2/4/99......... Division II of Motion Rejected 1678
House Managers' 30-70.
motion re:
appearance of
witnesses.
11....... 2/4/99......... Murray motion to Motion Rejected 1680
substitute 27-73.
Division III of
House Managers'
motion.
12....... 2/4/99......... Division III of Motion Agreed to 1681
House Managers' 62-38.
motion re:
presentation of
evidence.
13....... 2/4/99......... Daschle motion to Motion Rejected 1682
proceed to 44-56.
closing arguments.
14....... 2/4/99......... White House Motion Rejected 1685
Counsel's motion 46-54.
on video
deposition
excerpts.
15....... 2/9/99......... Lott motion to Motion Rejected 1965
suspend the rules. 59-41.
16....... 2/9/99......... Lott motion to Motion Agreed to 1970
close the doors. 53-47.
17....... 2/12/99........ Impeachment Not Guilty 45-55. 1995
Article I.
18....... 2/12/99........ Impeachment Not Guilty 50-50. 1997
Article II.
19....... 2/12/99........ Gramm motion to Motion Rejected 2003
postpone 43-56.
consideration of
rules suspension
motion.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
VOLUME III: DEPOSITIONS AND AFFIDAVITS
Deposition of Monica S. Lewinsky (Feb. 1, 1999) (full transcript) 2027
Deposition of Vernon E. Jordan, Jr. (Feb. 2, 1999) (full
transcript).................................................... 2224
Deposition of Sidney Blumenthal (Feb. 3, 1999) (full transcript). 2399
Affidavit of Christopher Hitchens (Feb. 5, 1999)................. 2534
Affidavit of Carol Blue (Feb. 7, 1999)........................... 2535
Affidavit of R. Scott Armstrong (Feb. 8, 1999)................... 2536
VOLUME IV: STATEMENTS OF SENATORS REGARDING THE IMPEACHMENT TRIAL OF
PRESIDENT WILLIAM JEFFERSON CLINTON \5\
February 12, 1999
Sen. Specter \6\................................................. 2537
Sen. Gorton...................................................... 2537
Sen. Feingold \7\................................................ 2545
Sen. Hutchison................................................... 2548
Sen. Conrad...................................................... 2558
Sen. Hutchinson.................................................. 2561
Sen. Murray...................................................... 2563
Sen. McCain...................................................... 2565
Sen. Johnson..................................................... 2567
Sen. Lugar....................................................... 2570
Sen. Biden....................................................... 2573
Sen. Abraham..................................................... 2616
Sen. Mikulski.................................................... 2622
Sen. Grams....................................................... 2625
Sen. Breaux...................................................... 2627
Sen. Domenici.................................................... 2630
Sen. Sarbanes.................................................... 2633
Sen. Campbell.................................................... 2637
Sen. Kerrey...................................................... 2639
Sen. Voinovich................................................... 2641
Sen. Lautenberg.................................................. 2643
Sen. Bond \8\.................................................... 2646
Sen. Robb........................................................ 2652
Sen. Boxer....................................................... 2656
Sen. Mack........................................................ 2659
Sen. Fitzgerald.................................................. 2672
Sen. Roth........................................................ 2681
Sen. Burns....................................................... 2684
Sen. Inhofe \9\.................................................. 2685
Sen. Cleland..................................................... 2689
Sen. Frist....................................................... 2694
Sen. Bunning..................................................... 2703
Sen. Durbin...................................................... 2706
Sen. Kyl......................................................... 2710
Sen. Specter..................................................... 2715
Sen. Levin....................................................... 2738
Sen. Kohl........................................................ 2758
Sen. Thompson.................................................... 2761
Sen. Moynihan.................................................... 2789
Sen. Graham...................................................... 2792
Sen. Allard...................................................... 2794
Sen. McConnell................................................... 2799
Sen. Kennedy..................................................... 2807
Sen. Collins..................................................... 2812
Sen. Harkin...................................................... 2814
Sen. Reid........................................................ 2826
Sen. Edwards..................................................... 2830
Sen. Akaka....................................................... 2833
Sen. Leahy \10\.................................................. 2837
Sen. Grassley.................................................... 2867
Sen. Craig....................................................... 2870
Sen. Dodd \11\................................................... 2873
Sen. Jeffords.................................................... 2877
Sen. Wellstone................................................... 2884
Sen. Stevens..................................................... 2888
Sen. Lieberman................................................... 2892
Sen. Brownback................................................... 2905
Sen. Bryan....................................................... 2913
Sen. Ashcroft.................................................... 2917
Sen. Thurmond.................................................... 2934
Sen. Crapo....................................................... 2937
Sen. Dorgan...................................................... 2939
Sen. Kerry....................................................... 2943
Sen. DeWine...................................................... 2948
Sen. Lincoln..................................................... 2956
Sen. Helms....................................................... 2959
Sen. Hollings.................................................... 2962
Sen. Wyden....................................................... 2965
Sen. Smith (Ore.)................................................ 2967
Sen. Hagel....................................................... 2971
Sen. Rockefeller................................................. 2972
Sen. Murkowski................................................... 2977
Sen. Byrd........................................................ 2981
Sen. Inhofe...................................................... 2987
Sen. Leahy....................................................... 2996
Sen. Snowe....................................................... 3000
February 22, 1999
Sen. Nickles..................................................... 3005
Sen. Landrieu.................................................... 3013
Sen. Smith (N.H.)................................................ 3016
Sen. Bingaman.................................................... 3022
Sen. Bennett..................................................... 3024
Sen. Reed \12\................................................... 3026
Sen. Enzi........................................................ 3033
Sen. Feingold.................................................... 3042
February 23, 1999
Sen. Daschle..................................................... 3053
Sen. Bond........................................................ 3058
Sen. Sessions \13\............................................... 3059
Sen. Coverdell................................................... 3063
Sen. Hatch....................................................... 3066
Sen. Leahy....................................................... 3090
Sen. Sessions.................................................... 3094
Sen. Dodd........................................................ 3099
Sen. Leahy....................................................... 3102
February 24, 1999
Sen. Reed........................................................ 3103
\1\ On December 19, 1998, the House of Representatives agreed to H.
Res. 611, 105th Cong., the Articles of Impeachment, [144 Cong. Rec.
H12040-42 (daily ed. Dec. 19, 1998)] and H. Res. 614, 105th Cong.,
which provided for the appointment of managers and procedures relating
to impeachment proceedings [id. at H12042-43].
\2\ The House of Representatives agreed to H. Res. 10, 106th Cong.,
on January 6, 1999 [145 Cong. Rec. H216-17 (daily ed. Jan. 6, 1999)].
\3\ The Appendix to Trial Memorandum of President William Jefferson
Clinton, consisting of exhibits, was filed separately on January 20,
1999, but is inserted here for ease of reference.
\4\ For ease of reference, the documents contained in S. Doc. 106-
2, i.e., the pertinent constitutional provisions, the Senate
Impeachment Rules, the Articles of Impeachment, the Answer of President
Clinton, and the Replication of the House of Representatives, are
reprinted in this publication. Separately, the Senate admitted into
evidence and authorized the printing, pursuant to S. Res. 16, 106th
Cong., of the publicly available materials submitted to or produced by
the House Judiciary Committee, including transcripts of public hearings
or mark-ups and any materials printed by the House of Representatives
or the House Judiciary Committee pursuant to H. Res. 525 and H. Res.
581, 105th Cong. (1998). That evidentiary record, S. Doc. 106-3 (1999)
[24 vols.], is not reproduced here.
\5\ The unanimous-consent agreement of February 9, 1999, allowed
each Senator to place in the Congressional Record his or her statement
delivered during closed deliberations. Not all Senators chose to
publish their remarks; the fact that a statement of a particular
Senator does not appear here does not mean that Senator did not address
the Senate during the closed sessions. Additionally, the unanimous-
consent agreement of February 12, 1999, allowed Senators to have
statements and opinions explaining their votes printed in the
Congressional Record.
\6\ Sen. Specter submitted an additional statement on February 12,
see p. 2715 below.
\7\ Sen. Feingold submitted an additional statement on February 22,
see p. 3042 below.
\8\ Sen. Bond submitted an additional statement on February 23, see
p. 3058 below.
\9\ Sen. Inhofe submitted an additional statement on February 12,
see p. 2987 below.
\10\ Sen. Leahy submitted additional statements on February 12 and
February 23, see pp. 2996, 3090, 3102 below.
\11\ Sen. Dodd submitted additional statements on February 23, see
pp. 3099 and 3100 below.
\12\ Sen. Reed submitted an additional statement on February 24,
see p. 3103 below.
\13\ Sen. Sessions submitted an additional statement on February
23, see p. 3094 below.